Fibre-reinforced shotcrete is an essential part of the support of hard rock tunnels. Due to the complexity of the design, a combination of empirical and numerical analysis is commonly used in the design. The required dosage of fibres for structural purposes is determined based on minimum energy absorption or residual flexural strength. The latter is derived from tests on beams, while energy absorption is tested on panels. It is widely known that tests on beams suffer from a large scatter in results due to the short fracture zone in combination with the natural variation in the number and orientation of fibres which bridge the crack. This impacts the characteristic strength derived from these tests negatively. This paper presents a numerical study to investigate how the test method affects the required dosage of fibres. First, a non-linear model for shotcrete based on continuum damage mechanics is presented. Thereafter, the model is tuned against test results for beams and panels. A model tuned on beams is then used to simulate the response of a panel and vice versa. The results indicate that the size of the fracture zone has a significant effect on the post-cracking behaviour and that the required dosage of fibres could be decreased if specimens with longer fracture zones, i.e., panels or slabs, are used.